Don't see your favorite in poll results? Nominate A Candidate

Nunzio's Pizza
Scotch Plains, NJ
2 Votes
Castelli's Pizza Kitchen
Butler, NJ
1 Votes
Giulietta & Romeo Pizzeria
East Hanover, NJ
1 Votes
Lola's Restaurant
Robbinsville, NJ
1 Votes
Domino's Pizza - Coming Soon
Elmwood Park, NJ
1 Votes
Mi Familia
Mantua, NJ
1 Votes
New York Style Pizza
Gloucester City, NJ
1 Votes
Napoli Pizza
Lodi, NJ
1 Votes
Lovey's Pizzeria & Ristorante
Hasbrouck Heights, NJ
1 Votes
Marcello’s Italian Ristorante
Berkeley Heights, NJ
1 Votes
Antonio's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Warren, NJ
1 Votes
Denny's Pizza
Carlstadt, NJ
1 Votes
Tony Soprano's Pizza
Hammonton, NJ
1 Votes
Taste of Italy Ristorante & Pizzeria
Hackettstown, NJ
1 Votes
Cristo's Pizza & Grill
North Brunswick, NJ
1 Votes
Sicilia Pizza Pizza
Clayton, NJ
1 Votes
Turvino's Pizzeria and Restaurant
Glen Rock, NJ
1 Votes
Dominic's Pizza
Waretown, NJ
1 Votes
Gencarellis Of Lyndhurst
Lyndhurst, NJ
1 Votes
Brother's Pizza
Saddle Brook, NJ
1 Votes
Attilio's Restaurant & Pizza
Long Branch, NJ
1 Votes
Lavallette Trattoria & Pizzeria
Lavallette, NJ
1 Votes
Frank's Pizza Italian Restaurant & Catering
Lincoln Park, NJ
1 Votes
Mr. Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Rochelle Park, NJ
1 Votes
Keyport Pizza & Restaurant
Keyport, NJ
1 Votes

Don't see your favorite in poll results? Nominate A Candidate